I don't buy them!
With barely 20 days to go for final book to go... I have been surfing the internet… and reading theories that fans have been posting on sites all over the world… Some of these theories are really cool, very believable and something that every keen reader can relate to! But this post is not about those theories… this post is about those theories that kind of crack me up! Of course just because I don’t believe it doesn’t mean they can’t be true! So keep predicting!- Dumbledore the Gryffindor heir: Don’t know why but this doesn’t sound convincing as it doesn’t serve any purpose in the storyline!
- Dumbledore asked Snape to make a horcrux by killing him: Come on again… why would anyone want to do that?
- Ron will die in the final book: While this isn’t really unbelievable, I just don’t see why Ronald Weasley should perish!
- Snape is really evil: No way!
- Some form of Sirius will come back: Well unless it is something like Harry’s parents coming out of Voldemort’s wand… I genuinely don’t believe any of the dead are going to rise from their grave!
- Ginny is a horcrux: I have seen this one on a lot many websites… and Ginny as a horcrux, no matter what the reason, doesn’t seem acceptable.
- Harry a horcrux: I have seen this all over the place too! If Harry is a horcrux… then JK definitely hints at killing Harry off! If the horcrux has the go… Harry has to go too! Which despite all those talks about Harry not living upto adulthood, is still unrealistic!
- Kreacher accompanies RAB (Regulus) to the cave: Don’t know why but no… it’s too huge a job for a Kreacher to do it! Thus, I also rule out the Kreacher having the locket theory!
- Dumbledore is alive because he made a horcrux: Anyone who has followed Dumbledore will laugh and it won’t be a happy one!
- Crookshanks is an animagus: Some people actually said Crookshanks may actually be RAB J. I really don’t think so!
- Snape was in love with Lily: Somehow, it’s difficult to think that a person in love would call the object of his admiration mudblood…
- Wormtail accompanied Voldemort to Godrics Hollow: Once Voldemort got the information, I don’t see any reason why Wormtail would be taken to the Potter house.
Feel free to add your share of theories you don’t believe in… or any other comment you so wish!
posted by hermionegranger | 11:02 am
3 Comments:
Finally after 5 months, Hermione breaks her silence... and that too in the potter month. Hopefully we will have more posts from her before the final book arrives and of course more after that.
As for the theories, I am sure there are more out there which may completely be useless and others which may appear useless now, but are indeed in the next book. Also there is another possibility that JKR wiggled her way through all the theories and made sure that none of them are in her final book.
But we will have to wait and watch... wouldn't we?
- Remus
Crookshanks/Mrs. Norris being Animagi have been flatly denied by JKR.
Kreacher accompanying RAB does make sense.
BTW - if some of you still doubt whther RAB could be someone else -
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R.A.B.
should clear it up - especially the foreign books part.
But there's something about Harry's eyes which is gonna be important - wonder what that is?
Good words.
Post a Comment
<< Home